WATERVILLE, Ohio — An amphitheater project in Waterville that began over a year ago split the community, prompted legal action and eventually flamed out as the developer cut his losses and set his sights on opportunities in Toledo.
For some voters in Tuesday's general election, the divisive amphitheater played a role in who they cast their ballots for.
Three people to Waterville City Council: Anthony Garver received the most votes with 1,158, incumbent Todd Borowski received 1,100 votes and Wayne Wagner followed closely behind with 1,069 votes.
"I’m humbled, surprised,” Garver said. “Being a first-time candidate, I didn't know what to expect."
Garver says he initially supported the controversial amphitheater project. But when he learned more, he changed his mind.
He thinks the project drew some voter turnout, but said he believes people elected him for more.
"I think they liked my message,” Garver said. “My message wasn't focused on the amphitheater. It was really more focused on the communication. If that piece was done a little bit better, I don't think we would have the stir we had."
The stir was felt by the owner of Farnsworth Cocktail Bar, Josh Wagy.
He said he doesn't want to talk about the amphitheater project, but he knows there are strong opinions.
"People come in and ask, 'where do you stand?' Almost like they won't come here and eat,” Wagy said.
Wagy is a supporter of Mayor Tim Pedro, even having signs in front of the restaurant. Pedro was elected for another term on Tuesday and wants to move on from the amphitheater project.
"I think folks try to make this election about one issue but there's so much going on," Pedro said.
He would also like to focus on helping the new council members transition into their positions.
"As I said to one of them this morning, 'I'm one vote, you're one vote, so we have to work together.' I'm sure we will as we go forward," Pedro said.